
(Note: Sample material is taken from uncorrected proofs. Changes
may be made prior to publication.)
Israel
Background
Material
Israel received its independence in 1948. Its total area measures
some 28,000 square kilometers and its population is about 7 million.
About 80% of the population are Jews, 20% are Arabs. Over half
of Israeli Jews are native-born, while the rest hail from over
eighty countries around the world. Some 90% of Israel's inhabitants
live in over 100 urban centers, including the country's four major
cities: Jerusalemthe capital cityTel Aviv, Haifa and
Beer-Sheba. The language of the country is Hebrew, and Arabic
is the second official tongue.
The GDP of
Israel in 2001 was 105,425 million dollars. The per capita GDP
was 16,364 million dollars. 17% of the GDP is from industry; more
than half of the high-tech product is exported. 43% of the GDP
comes from imports, while 34% comes from exports. Israel's diamond
industry produces about 80% of the world output of small polished
stones. The average inflation has decreased to 3-4% in recent
years.
The major
challenge for Israel is to arrive at a peace settlement with the
Palestinians and with other neighboring Arab States (Syria and
Lebanon). The insecurity which exists in the country and the constant
state of war and terror cause discontent within the population,
and also a decrease in investments from abroad, a complete standstill
in the tourism industry and generally, a decrease in economic
growth.
Israel is
a democratic republic with a parliamentary multiparty system of
government. The principle of separation of powers is maintained,
with three branches of government: the legislature (the Knesset
is a 120-member, single chamber legislature whose members are
elected every four years); the executive (the Government of Israel,
in which the Prime Minister leads a coalition government); and
the judiciary (Israeli courts). The Knesset elects the President
(elected for a seven-year term, not renewable), who is the Head
of State and exercises mainly ceremonial functions.
Israel does
not have a formal written constitution, although the Declaration
of Independence and a body of legislation provide for a gradual
build up for a future planned Constitution. Israel's Supreme Courtacting
as a High Court of Justicecan suggest the desirability of
legislative changes and can rule on constitutional and administrative
matters.
Contextual
Features
The Israeli criminal justice system is adversarial in nature,
and the judicial proceedings are in the hands of professional
judges, elected by a public committee. Like in many other western
systems, the criminal process in Israel is composed of two stages:
the trial and the sentencing process. The judge decides if the
accused is found guilty or innocent, based on the indictment and
the material evidence. During the sentencing process, the judge
is allowed to sentence the accused to any length of imprisonment
below the maximum limit or to apply more lenient alternatives
to imprisonment. Death penalty as criminal punishment for murder,
was in existence until 1954, when it was abolished and replaced
by a mandatory life sentence.
In criminal
hearings, district attorneys represent the State and the Attorney
General heads the Prosecutorial Branch. During the entire prosecutorial
process, the prosecutor invokes the process of indictment and
has the right to offer a plea bargain to the suspect or his/her
attorneys. In magistrate courts, police prosecutors usually prosecute
misdemeanors.
Children
between the ages of 14 to 18 can be prosecuted, but are tried
in special juvenile courts.
Every criminal
suspect or accused has the right to choose an attorney who will
represent him/her. The court has the right, to appoint an attorney,
free of charge, if the defendant cannot afford one. In 1996, the
Office of Public Defender was established and it employs both
in-house and private attorneys.
The court
system is three-tiered: 1. Magistrates' (or Peace) Courts, which
exercise criminal jurisdiction on crimes punishable by no more
than seven years of imprisonment or fine. Most of the proceedings
in these courts are conducted before a single judge; 2. District
Courts, which deal with all criminal cases beyond the jurisdiction
of the Magistrates' Courts, and also serve as appellate courts
for the District Courts' verdicts and other decision. A three-judge
panel is appointed in serious cases; 3. The Supreme Court exercises
jurisdiction over the District Courts' decisions. In addition,
this court serves as the state's Supreme Court, sitting as a High
Court of Justice. In this case, it functions as an administrative
law court to provide judicial review of official administrative
actions.
There is
only one national prison system in Israel, which includes maximum,
medium, and minimum security prisons, which serve general or particular
populations (e.g., women and youth). Its principal role is the
safe incarceration of the inmates and prevention of the inmates
from causing harm to the society. This system also claims to have
a role in the rehabilitation of the incarcerated population (The
Prison Ordinance, 1971). The system is headed by the Prisons Commissioner,
who is appointed by the Minister of Public Security.
The Ministry
of Labour and Social Affairs is responsible for correctional services
and for the probation systemsboth juvenile and adult (Hasin
& Horovitz, 1998 ). The Ministry also deals with correctional
and treatment services for youths at-risk and at-risk familiesincluding
the institutions, hostels and half-way houses used for these populationsas
well and adolescents who have been placed outside their home environment
by a juvenile court order, and who were designated as "minors
in need of protection" because of serious physical, social
or emotional neglect. (Sebba et al., 2003).
The Anti-Drug
Authority (ADA) coordinates all anti-drug strategy throughout
the country, including enforcement activity with the police, education
and publicity campaigns, legislation, treatment and community
prevention activity (www.antidrug.org.il; Sebba & Horovitz,
2000)
Crimes in
Israel are classified into three categories: crimes/felonies,
misdemeanors, and administrative violations. The police compile
the daily number of complaints reported by victims or offences
detected by the police, and record and transfer the data to the
Central Bureau of Statistics (CBS), which publishes them monthly.
After a relatively
steady climb in crime rates for 15 years (until 1997) (Rahav,
1998)especially in property crime, which constitutes, on
average, about 60% of the total recorded crimethere was
some decline in recorded crime (in absolute numbers) as well as
in the crime rate (files recorded per capita) from 1998 to 2002
(See Table). However, in 2003 there was again an increase in reported
overall crime (+4.2% from the previous year). (See Table 1).
Property
crime (including all thefts and break-ins) increased during the
early 90s and reached a peak in 1997- 1998. Car theft, for instance,
rose due to the relative ease in moving the stolen cars and dismantling
or changing their identities within the Palestinian Territories,
where the Israeli police had difficulty entering. In an endeavor
to decrease this problem, a law has been passed which allows the
legal selling of car-parts only by authorized dealers who trade
in parts that have been marked and registered. Anyone selling
un-marked parts will be prosecuted for selling stolen parts. House
and business burglary and thefts of all kinds constitute a serious
problem, both in terms of the economic impact on society and the
traumatic effect these have on the victims, throughout the years.
During periods in which there is increased terrorist activityas
in the present "Intifada" (Palestinian uprising)(since
the fall of 2000)various anti-terrorist techniques are put
into place, such as the closure of the West Bank and Gaza Strip
to Palestinian workers, who would otherwise come to work in Israel.
There seems to be a correlation between the decrease in crime
rates and these periods of "closure"probably because
of the increase in police patrolling presence, increased police
and army personnel surveillance at check-points and the decrease
in the number of Israeli offenders, who prior to the Intifada,
committed crimes together with Palestinian offenders, freely entering
and exiting the Palestinian territories (Herzog, 2003).
Violent crime,
has also been on the rise in the last few yearsespecially
perpetrated by youth and organized gangsperhaps also due
to increased use of alcohol and drugs and culture-conflict of
new immigrants. There was a steady rise in domestic violence in
the mid 90swhich may be due to an increased reporting rate
because of increased public awareness to the problem of domestic
and spouse abuse. However, in the last few years there has been
a decrease in such cases, perhaps due to increased enforcement
policy of the police and immediate arrest of abusing men.
Other major
changes that have occurred in the last five years include the
strengthening and infiltration of organized groups of criminals
(many from abroad), who use Israel as a base for money laundering
and for setting up gambling, prostitution and drug-trafficking
rings (Amir, 1998; Landau, 1998). Furthermore, there is an increase
in fraud and so-called "white collar crimes"especially
within financial institutions. In recent years, there is an increase
in the number of illegal foreign workers living and working in
Israel. Their status precipitates other illegal activitysuch
as forgery of documents and fraud, trafficking in women for prostitution,
property crime and violent offences. In 2002 a special unit in
the Police has been established to deal expressly with enforcement
issues regarding illegal workers.
Drug trafficking
and drug abuse have also been on the rise, although in the last
few years there has been a slight decrease in drug abuse by youth.
However, there has also been a decrease in the age in which drug
abuse begins (Anti-Drug Authority Annual Reports: www.antidrugs.org.il).
Traffic accidents
pose a continuous problem, causing about 500 fatalities a year
and between thirty to forty thousand injured. Since 2000, there
is a slight but steady decline in the number of fatal and other
accidents around the country, each year.(www.police.gov.il)
There have
been four victim surveys made by the Ministry of Public Security
since 1979 and until 2001. During the last survey (2001) (Central
Bureau of Statistics, 2002) it was found that the victimization
rate against persons is 10.2 and 7.3 pertaining to property crime,
while only 37.5 % reported crimes against the person while 45%
reported property crime to the police.
Police
Profile
Background
After the foundation of the state, in 1948, a Ministry of Police
was founded, to supervise both the Israel Police (henceforth,
IP) and the Israel Prison Service; a single Commissioner for both
the Israel Police and the Israel Prison Service reported directly
to the Israeli Cabinet. From 1952, however, these functions were
split.
In 1953,
the Border Guard was set up within the IP to combat the problem
of terrorist infiltrators and to patrol the State's frontiers.
In the mid 50s, the police force was organized geographically
into districts. In 1958, the growing demand for police services,
forced the police to separate national staff work from field units.
Its manpower and equipment establishment was codified; its investigations
department went over to a proactive crime prevention strategy;
beat-policemen and juvenile crime units made their first appearance
and policewomen were given operational duties. In the 50s and
60s the Forensic Laboratory was upgraded and a mobile scene-of-crime
laboratory introduced. In the early 70s, candidates with a university
education and ex-army officers were recruited directly to officer-rank
positions. Technological and scientific advances were absorbed
more and more into police work. Due to numerous Palestinian terrorist
attacks, the government, in April 1974, decided to hand over responsibility
for internal security within Israel, to the IP and this in turn
compelled the IP to make wide-ranging organizational changes to
accommodate its new responsibilities. The Civil Guard was set
up to mobilize, train, and equip tens of thousands of volunteers
for patrolling neighborhood streets. The Special Anti-Terrorist
Unit and the Bomb Disposal Division were set up. The IP created
its Operations Division in 1975 to coordinate and streamline the
work of all operational branches. In the early 80s the Community
Relations Unit was set up. By the mid 90s, police officers' working
conditions and welfare improved. Applications for recruitment
had risen and the service set out to reevaluate its recruitment,
placement, and training system, placing the emphasis on efficient
and reliable service to the public, and encouraging ordinary citizens
to extend their confidence in, and cooperation with, the police.
IP intelligence services were overhauled putting emphasis on drug-trafficking
detection and enforcement. Special units were deployed on the
borders and ports of the country. Early in 1995, the Community
Policing Unit was created, whose brief was to make policing more
responsive to the needs of the ordinary citizen and to integrate
the resources and goals of the police with those of Local Government
Authorities and community agencies and services. 1995 saw also
the creation of the Traffic Administration to coordinate the handling
of urban and inter-city road traffic. In 1997, the IP's new Code
of Ethics was officially introduced. Since 2000 to date, many
police officers have been killed in the line of duty by terrorists
and a majority of the patrolling police are occupied with security
matters. However, other problems plague the country: increased
youth violence, computer and internet crime, white-collar crime,
trafficking in drugs and drug-abuse, women and arms - some by
organized crime rings. These have made it necessary for the police
to set-up special intelligence and operative units along the borders
of the country, to upgrade international cooperation, to upgrade
the computerized data bases of the IP, as well as to set-up computer
crime units to deal more efficiently with a variety of new types
of crimes.
Organizational
Description
The force is commanded and directed, operationally and organizationally,
by its Commissioner (known as "Inspector-General"),
who is appointed by the Government on the recommendation of the
Minister of Public Security. The Commissioner has no political
affiliations and is usually a veteran police officer. Units attached
to the national headquarters and directly responsible to the Commissioner
are: the Office of the Legal Counsel, the Office of the Spokesperson,
Accounting, the Office of the Internal Auditor and Ombudsperson,
the Disciplinary Court, and Disciplinary Appeals Court, the Operational
Safety Unit the Quality Service Unit and the Illegal Immigrant
Unit.
Eight Departments
constitute the IP's national headquarters, which is situated in
Jerusalem, the capital of Israel: Investigations and Crime Fighting,
Patrol and Security, Intelligence, Traffic, Logistics, Personnel,
Planning, and the Community and Civil Guard.
The functions
of the IP's national HQ Departmentseach in its field of
expertiseinclude professional guidance and training to the
units in the field; policy and decision making; gathering and
analyzing data; research and development; logistic support; resource
allocation; review of operations and procedures; coordination
with other departments and with external agencies.
The main
computer systems are at HQcontaining the criminal files,
10-print fingerprint and palm print files of all convicted offenders,
stolen vehicle files, and many other data bases, received from
other Ministriessuch as names, addresses and identification
numbers of all adults in Israel, registration of all weapons and
their ownership, vehicle registration and driving licenses.
There are
nationally based units that are under the direct supervision of
the Patrol and Operations Department: The Helicopter Unit; the
National Vehicle Theft Prevention Unit; and a National Negotiation
Teamused when hostage situations arise.
There are
two national investigation units: one for serious and international
crimes, (such as the operation of car theft rings, and drug-trafficking)
and the second for dealing with white-collar crime, fraud and
computer-crime.
Divided into
geographic areas, the IP is organized into District Commands (in
2004there were 7 Districts, however, the number has changed
over the yearssometimes through integration and sometimes
through separation). The District Commanders are directly responsible
to the Police Commissioner. The District Commanders and the Department
Heads at HQall hold the rank of Major General - and compromise
the Senior Command Staff of the Commissioner.
These Districts
are divided again into Sub-Districts, each of which is under the
direction of a Police Commander. These are, in turn, divided into
large Regional Police Stations or smaller Police Stations and
Police Sub-Stations. To date (2004), there are 10 large Regional
Stations (mostly in the metropolitan centers); 53 stations, about
100 sub-stations, about 360 community policing centersusually,
one-man police centers in neighborhoods or rural villages but
sometimes a mobile or temporary centers set up in a specific area
to deal with specific problemsand about 400 neighborhood
Civil Guard Bases. The commanding officers of the police units,
are all selected by national and regional headquarters: town mayors
or other heads of locally elected councils have no say in these
appointments.
Each of the
Districts and Sub-Districts is managed by an administrative and
operational headquarters that parallels the organization of the
central IP Headquarters in Jerusalem: i.e. Police functions such
as investigations, patrol and security, traffic, personnel management,
community and (volunteer) Civil Guard affairs, are all carried
out at national, district, sub-district and station levels. There
has been an attempt to flatten out the organizational structure
and do away with the middle management (Sub-District) levels.
This is a slow process that has yet to be completed. Furthermore,
a strategic plan, set up by the Community and Civil Guard Dept.,
will decrease the number of Civil Guard Bases by joining them
up with the existing and planned Community Policing Centers.
The budget
of the IP is provided by the National Budget and none is provided
by municipal or other taxes. However, there are some services,
provided by the police, that are paid for by the bodies or agencies
receiving these services. These funds are channeled through the
Ministry of Finance, to the IP.
In the last
ten years the budget distribution has been as follows: over 75%
for salaries; 22% for procurement; about 3% for R & D.
Demographics
and Training
As of 2004, the Israel Police employs some 25,700 policemen and
women, including soldiers doing their compulsory military service
in the IP; 20% of this total, are women. Virtually all staff is
enlisted to the Police. Only since 1999 has the organization begun
to civilianize some of the jobs - especially secretarial and logistical
support jobs. This trend increases each year.
On an average,
(since 1995 to 2000) more than 1,000 men and women are recruited
to the IP each year, the majority, for the core duties of patrol
work, investigations, intelligence, traffic control, bomb disposal,
and the Community and Civil Guard. There are some 8,000 Border
Guard police officers12% of them comprising of police officers
from the ethnic minorities in Israel (Bedouin, Circassian, Christians,
Druze and Moslems). Some of the police officers are recruited
to the Border Guard as part of their compulsory military training
(3 years for males, and 2 years for females), after completing
their high-school studies at 18. Some of these continue on to
a police career as regular police officers. In 1995, an amendment
to the Security Service Act came into effect, enabling young men
and women, to do their compulsory military service in other branches
of the police. Since then, hundreds each year have made this choice.
The Organizational
Behavior Division at HQ, is responsible for the selection process
of all recruitscovering psychological and physical health,
security clearance, schooling and intelligence testing of candidates,
who are examined for general suitability and for suitability to
a particular area of activity of the IP. All candidates are obligated
to have completed High School (12 years) and taken their matriculation
exams. Police officers are assessed for placement and for promotion
using testing, interviews, simulations - individually and in groupsand
by the use of "assessment centers." An officer leaves
the Service by personal request, retirement, or dismissal. The
age for compulsory retirement is 55, but many retire at the age
of 50 as wellreceiving pension payments according to the
years which they served (2% of their present salary, for each
year of service).
On the whole,
the working salary and the working conditions of the police officers
are above the average in the Israeli public sector workforce.
The Commissioned Officers' salary is "linked" to that
of army personnel.
A new police
officer, once recruited, participates in a basic 25-week training
course which consists of 4 weeks of physical training, 7 week
of general police training and 14 weeks of specific police training.
An officer must work for at least 3 years on the job, before possible
promotion to the next rank. A proficiency test in his area of
work must be passed. After another year on the job, the officer
can be recommended by his/her commanders to go to the "Advanced
Police-Officers' Course"a 4-6 weeks' specialized training
course. During the fifth year in the service, the officer is also
eligible to go to the "Senior Police-Officers' Course"
for those police officers who are slated to become commanders
of units. This 5-10 week course, concentrates on material pertaining
to the particular field of specialty of the police officer. Only
after this second training course can a police-officer be recommended
for promotion to Commissioned Officer (CO) status and take part
in the CO Course which takes 30 weeks. During this training course,
the officers also take part in academic studies for one semester
at the Haifa University (for those who do not have academic degrees).
For those who are slated to become Commanders of bureaus in police
stations, a further 6 weeks' training in their particular area
of work is necessary. For Police Station Commanders, a 13 week
command and leadership course is given. For those appointed to
be Sub-Division or a Regional Station Commander, there is a further
6 week Senior Management Course.
Promotion
from rank to rank is achieved by seniority, completion of training
courses and individual evaluationboth by commanders and
peers. There are seven non-commissioned officer ranks and nine
CO ranks.
Police officers
having academic degrees are also recruited to the lowest rank,
but can advance to Commissioned Officer, if they pass the assessment
center and complete the Commissioned-Officer's Course, after about
one year of service.
A new National
Police Training Academy, is being built and will include specially
designed training areas for different police activities. There
is a separate Senior Officer's Training Academy, which provides
the training in management and planning, and The Operational Fitness
Academy which trains the police officers for self-defense, crowd
dispersal, use of firearms and non-lethal weapons, moving around
an urban environment and subduing a suspect.
Functions
The Israel Police, from its inception in 1948, has been a national,
highly centralized force. Under the Israel National Police Ordinance
(Revised Version), 1971, which defines functions and powers of
the IP, the Police is responsible for the maintenance of law and
order; for crime prevention; for traffic control; for the apprehension
and remanding of criminals and suspected criminals; for securing
public order and for safeguarding life and property; and for providing
secure environment for detainees. (IP internet web site: www.police.gov.il,
2003).
In 1974 an
additional responsibility was given to the IPmaintaining
internal security and providing anti-terrorist activity within
the borders of the country.
There are
approximately 2,500 investigators (2003) and prosecutors. Police
prosecutors present criminal cases to the Magistrate Courts, when
dealing with all misdemeanors and some felonies. When a complaint
has been reported to the police, and when there is reasonable
belief that a crime has been committed, the police open a file
and start an investigation. If the suspected offence is a misdemeanour
or contravention, a police Commissioned Officer, with the rank
of Captain (Chief Inspector) or higher, has the authority to decide
that an inquiry falls within the jurisdiction of another agency
having investigative and enforcement powers. In certain cases,
there may be grounds for deciding not to investigate further or
not to indict the suspect. In this case the person who reported
the offence, receives a letter from the police stating the reasons
for the decision.
After gathering
the evidence, the police file is forwarded to the District Attorney's
office or to the police prosecution unit or to other legal administrative
units responsible for the prosecution of the crime. The responsible
agency must then review the evidence and decide whether to request
further clarification or investigation by the police, and whether
there is a strong enough case to go to trial.
The investigative
work is backed up by forensic science and criminal identification
units at sub-district and most police levels, and various specialist
units. The Investigation Department is also responsible for dealing
with juvenilesboth as suspects and as victimsfrom
ages 12 (the age of criminal responsibility) until the age of
18. Youth police investigators, at the various levels, are specially
trained, and in addition to their investigative work, also work
on preventive activity in the schools and exercise oversight on
places of entertainment that are considered of high-risk to youth.
They coordinate their activity with youth and community social
services at the city and neighborhood levels. There are also specially
trained "domestic violence investigators" to deal with
this offence.
A Victim
Support Unit provides the professional input on all policy and
its implementation regarding the support given to victims of crimeespecially
regarding special groups, such as those of domestic abuse, sexual
abuse, "helpless" victims (such as the mentally retarded)
or the aged.
The Division
of Identification and Forensic Sciences, analyzes evidence using
a range of tests (DNA, fingerprints, drugs, explosives and flammable
materials, ballistics, etc.) in its specialized laboratories at
HQ. Each regional subdivision has forensic technicians who are
sent to gather evidence from crime scenes. The evidence is sent
to the IP's central laboratories for further examination and for
presentation by forensic experts as evidence in court. In addition,
testing and evidence-gathering kits have been developed in-house
and with collaboration with academic institutions. There is an
Automatic Fingerprint Identification System (AFIS) at HQ which
helps compare latent fingerprints, found at the scenes of crime,
with the fingerprints in the central data bank of known criminals
and to authenticate the identification of suspects with the help
of their fingerprints.
Intelligence
efforts are concentrated on serious "target criminals"
in accordance with an evaluation that is made at the various strata
of the police hierarchy. All intelligence data is centrally computerized.
The intelligence units are responsible for all drug-related enforcement
work, as well as for international cooperation with foreign police
forces. Since 1949, Israel has been a member of INTERPOL, and
extensive operational cooperation takes place on a regular basis.
Several police representatives are stationed abroad, in order
to facilitate international investigations.
At the district
level, there are centralized intelligence units, whose task is
to gather evidence and do under-cover work. Detectives work out
of the stations at the local level, doing surveillance work, undercover
operations and gathering and analyzing intelligence.
Police officers
can detain, question, arrest and search a suspect, without a warrant,
if they have reasonable suspicion that an offence has been committed,
and if not arrested or detained, the suspect may cause harm to
a person, to the public or to the security of the country. Furthermore,
a police officer may arrest a suspect without a warrant if he
believes that the suspect may disrupt an investigation or tamper
with evidence or try to influence witnesses.
Upon the
suspect's arrest, the police officer must identify himself, notify
the suspect that he/she is under arrest, explain to him/her the
reason for the arrest and provide the arrestee with a copy of
the warrant, if such exists. According to the new Criminal Procedure
Law (Law Enforcement Powers and Arrest) 1996, the police have
to bring the detained suspect before a judge, in order to extend
remand in detention, no later than 24 hours after the initial
arrest if the suspect is an adult, and no later than 12 hours,
if the suspect is a minor under 14 years of age. The court may
extend the period of detention for up to a maximum of 15 days.
Usually, however, the court extends the period for 5 days at a
time. ( Haberfeld and Herzog, 2000; Sebba et al., 2003)
The IP has
10 detention centers (cells for holding suspects while they are
under investigation and before prosecution or trial), at its disposal
throughout the country. Most police stations also have some detention
cells. Youth, adult men, and adult women are each confined separately,
as required by law.
The patrol
and operations units' chief responsibility is to respond to public
calls for assistance, usually telephoned into the Emergency Calls
Center by dialing '100'. They are the first line of response to
any emergency, whether road accident, natural disaster, or terrorist
attack.
At major
events and large gatherings, the patrol units take charge of maintaining
public order. If necessary, they are reinforced by officers drawn
from other units. In certain events that are run by a profit-making
body, the services of police-officers can be hired for an hourly
fee, in order to upgrade the standard police presence.
The Special
Patrol Units were established to give the IP a rapid response
capacity to incidents of particular severity or danger. Together
with the Border Guard's Special Units, they are the first to respond
to any life-endangering security incident or mass-casualty disaster.
They are routinely deployed against particularly dangerous criminal
targets or where there are geographical concentrations of criminal
activity. Any arm of the IP can call on them for immediate reinforcement.
The patrol
function uses cars, jeeps, motorcycles, scooters, dune-buggies,
boats, and helicopters as well as horse-patrol.
To help prevent
terrorist and criminal activity in residential areas, the Civil
Guard maintains a network of neighborhood Civil Guard Bases, run
by a police officer, whose task is to recruit and operates armed
mobile and foot patrols of volunteer citizens, run training programs
and organize rapid response teams for emergency duty.
Civil Guard
volunteers, aged 17 to 90, number annually approximately 70,000.
While on duty, the volunteers have police authority, and are usually
armed with police rifles and portable radio transmitters and identification
vests given them only while on duty. Regular volunteers must volunteer
for at least four hours per month, must undergo regular target
practice and other police training courses. The Civil Guard also
includes "special units" that provide volunteer aid
to regular police units in traffic control and enforcement, patrol
functions, emergency rescue units, agricultural theft prevention.
These uniformed volunteer units, undergo specialized training
and volunteer between 4 to 6 hours per week.
In 1994 the
IP began to implement the Community Policing strategy. The essence
of this approach is that the police should work in partnership
with local authorities and community agencies, all pooling their
resources to prevent or minimize crime, social problems that lead
to crime and incivilities that decrease the quality of life. Community
Police Officers were deployed to Community Policing Centers in
the rural areas and in the neighborhoods of large cities. Multi-agency
models for tackling different types of crimes are being implemented.
(Geva, 1995; 1998; 2003; Geva & Shem-Tov, 2002)
In 1999,
based on the COMPSTAT method used by the NYPD, computerization
of all policing activities was implemented, while linking the
stations to the central computer at HQ. This allows the local
police commanders as well as the management staff, to keep track
of changing crime and traffic accident patterns and plan preventive
and enforcement strategy.
The traffic
units enforce road traffic laws, investigates road accidents,
educate and informs the public in road discipline.
In the Traffic
Department specialists instruct other staff in traffic law enforcement,
handle prosecutions and investigates accidents; a strategic arm
looks for ways to upgrade staff skills and develop new detection
and enforcement technologies; an operational armthe National
Traffic Policeis responsible for enforcement and traffic
flow on inter-urban roads and, together with local city traffic
units, for enforcement campaigns inside towns. Specialized traffic
units at all levels from station to district, are assisted by
thousands of Civil Guard volunteers.
The "2000
Traffic Command Center" updates the public on traffic conditions,
by use of a system of CCTVs on major intersections and roadways.
Other technological advances, such as an automated traffic-light
camera ticket-issuing system, attempt to deal with the high rate
of traffic accidents in the country.
The Planning
Department manages all IP resources, its budget, its staff and
its data-banks. It coordinates all short- and long-range staff-work
and planning, designs systems and tools for planning and for the
collection and analysis of statistics. It also draws up and disseminates
Police Orders and NHQ Directives.
Under the
Technological Administration's remit comes responsibility for
developing and maintaining computer systems, building databanks,
and supplying data processing services as well as communications
systems to all police units. The IP is presently working to computerize
all patrol vehicles, all border crossing checks by persons and
vehicles, all police station work, the Investigations and Intelligence
Departments, and other units.
The Logistical
Support Department is charged with the management and care of
the IP's material supplies, building projects, vehicle and other
equipment procurement and maintenance and the provision of logistical
support to all IP operations and staff.
Dogs are
used mainly for drug and explosive detection, search and rescue
operations. Horses are used for patrol and crowd control.
Complaints
and Discipline
At each District level there is a Public Complaints Officer, who
can receive complaints from the public and investigate them. The
public can also send a complaint to the Police HQ Ombudsperson
or to the Ministry of Public Security Ombudsperson. The Discipline
Division draws up indictments to the IP's Disciplinary Court,
where hearings are heard before the Police Judge, two additional
Officers, who act as judges, and a "public representative,"
a lawyer from another agency. There is also an Appeals Court.
Complaints
which deal with suspected criminal matters or the un-lawful use
of force, are dealt with by the external "Department for
the Investigation of Complaints Against Police Officers",
under the supervision of the Ministry of Justice. It was set up
in 1992 following public pressure and a gradual change in the
attitudes regarding the issue of police accountability. Earlier,
all complaints against police officers were handled internally
by the IP. Less serious cases continue to be dealt with by the
Internal Investigations Unit within the IP. If the complaint is
sustained, then a Disciplinary Board hears the case and provides
judgment. All verdicts are subject to appeal and are then passed
onto the Disciplinary Appeals Board for further decision.
Training
in police ethics are a part of all police training courses, at
all stages of the police career (Geva 1995; Herzog 2000a; 2000b).
Terrorism
The IP is directly responsible for anti-terrorist activity and
for security of the population within the country's borders. Thus,
in 1995 responsibility for school perimeter security and, in 1997,
for public transport security was also added. For this assignment,
the IP has allocated a fleet of vehicle patrol units, briefed
to patrol the perimeter and vicinity of schools and other educational
institutions, and of bus, train, and taxi stations, to detect
and prevent terrorist or criminal activity.
The Patrol
and Operations Department is also responsible for providing input
regarding the security standards needed to enable the licensing
(by the local authority) of business premises, considered to be
of "high-risk." At local level, "business licensing
officers" make visits to business premises to check the attainment
of such standards, both before and upon renewal of licenses.
The IP's
Anti-Terrorist Special Combat Unit, which organizationally belongs
to the Border Guard, deals with terrorist activities within the
borders of the country, operates in hostage-taking situationsboth
terrorist and criminal in natureand sometimes assists in
the handling of serious public disturbances.
The Border
Guard Police is the para-military 'gendarmerie' force within the
IP, work under the supervision of the District Commanders. Its
tasks are to deal with security and anti-terrorist duties, to
guard and patrol the Israel-Palestinian Autonomous Area border,
to deal with public order disruptions and to prevent agricultural
theft.
Established
in 1975, the Bomb Disposal Division operates in the realm of both
criminal and terrorist sabotage activities. The bomb disposal
technicians, at the local level, handle about 100,000 calls per
year to check suspicious objects, parcels and cars, and lately-
suspected persons carrying bombs on their person. On average,
less than 1% of these calls involve actual incendiary or explosive
devices. An important aspect of their work is the prevention program,
which includes surveillance of crowded public areas and facilities,
and educational programs in the schools.
The HQ Division
has its own R&D Unit, to develop specialized equipment and
techniques as well as a separate laboratory to provide analysis
of explosive devises and modus operandi. The Israel Bomb Disposal
Information Center, gathers, analyzes and disseminates information
to police sappers and to other security organizations in the country
and worldwide.
International
Cooperation
Since the early 1970s there has been much international cooperation
between the IP and counterparts around the world in the following
areas of expertise: forensic sciencein which there is on-going
collaboration, in research and development, with many major laboratories
around the world. Joint projects have brought about development
of new methods in the area of fingerprint identification, explosive
analysis etc.
Another major
area of international cooperationand especially since the
early 90sis in the bomb disposal and anti-terrorist tactics,
equipment and technologies. Numerous international Memoranda of
Understandings have been signed with European and Asian countries
in this respect, and these have brought about exchanges of police
officers to study methods and techniques in the relevant countries
(Geva 1995).
Since the
late 1990s, Community Policing and especially the mobilization
of police volunteers, has been another major field of cooperation
with other countries (e.g. an exchange program with the State
of Georgia, U.S.A.)
Police
Research and Publications
No formal police research institute exists in Israel at present.
However, the Office of the Chief Scientist at the Ministry of
Public Security is responsible for the planning, coordination
and analysis of police related research. Each year, the Chief
Scientist solicits Requests for Proposals (RFPs) from the IP and
then chooses research groups (public or private) or agencies,
through a tender process, to undergo the research which was decided
upon for that year. This research varies from technological and
forensic R & D to the social sciences and management areas.
Within the police, various police departments have Research Sections,
which undergo small-scale research projects in their field of
activity. These include: forensic sciences, traffic enforcement,
technological and computer development projects, as well as in
the management areas, and community policing.
The Community
and Civil Guard Department at IP HQ publishes:
Marot
Hamishtara (Police Sights): a bi-monthly journal, disseminated
to all IP staff and IP pensioners as well as to journalists, judges,
Members of Knesset, and libraries. No subscription. In Hebrew.
Mishtara
Ve'Hevra (Police and Society): A reviewed academic annual
publication, including articles and research reports. No Subscription.
In Hebrew with English abstracts. Since its inception in 1997
it has produced 8 issues. Since 2000 it is published in cooperation
with the Senior Command School of the Israel Defense Forces (IDF).
Distributed to libraries, academic institutions and the Senior
Command of the IP and the IDF.
The Ministry
of Public SecurityInformation Services Division publishes
a yearly journal in English called: Innovation Exchange.
This publication publishes articles on the latest innovations
in crime prevention, law enforcement, corrections and incarceration.
A major chapter in this journal contains articles on innovations
and implementations in the IP. Since its inception in 1990 to
date (2004), it has put out 11 issues.
The following
are notable websites devoted to Israeli policing:
American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC): http:// www.us-israel.org
Central Bureau of Statistics: http://www.cbs.gov.il
Israel Police: http://www.police.gov.il
Israel Prison Service: http://ips.gov.il
Israel Anti Drug Authority: http://www.antidrugs.org.il
Ministry of Foreign Affairs: http://www.mfa.gov.il
Ruth
Geva and Sergio Herzog
Bibliography
Amir, Menahem. "Organized Crime in Israel", In Crime
and Criminal Justice in Israel: Assessing the Knowledge Base Toward
the Twenty-First Century, Edited by Robert R. Friedmann 121-138
State University of New York Press, Albany, USA, SUNY Series in
Israeli Studies, 1998.
Bensinger,
Gad. Justice in Israel: A Survey of Criminal Justice, Chicago:
University of Illinois, Office of International Criminal Justice,
1989.
______, "Crime
and Criminal Justice", In Crime and Criminal Justice in
Israel: Assessing the Knowledge Base Toward the Twenty-First Century,
Edited by Robert R. Friedmann, 43-61,State University of New York
Press, Albany, USA, SUNY Series in Israeli Studies, 1998.
Central Bureau of Statistics, Victimization Survey 2001,
October, Jerusalem, Israel, 2002 (Hebrew).
Geva, R.
"The Principles of Professional Ethics in Law Enforcement
in Israel as Pertaining to the Use of Force", In The Prevention
of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders in IsraelA Report,
Prepared for the Eighth UN Congress on the Prevention of Crime
and the Treatment of Offenders, Cuba, Aug. 1990, 80 -86. Jerusalem:
Ministry of Police, 1990.
______, "Effective
national and international action against terrorism: the Israeli
experience In The Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of
Offenders in Israel, Edited by Ruth Geva, Prepared for the
Eighth UN Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment
of Offenders, Cairo, Egypt, August, 1995, 71-84, 1995.
______, (1995).
"The Ministry of Police and the Israel National Police",
Police and Government Security Technology, (1995):98-101.
______, "Community
Policing in Israel", The Police Chief, vol. LXV, no.
12 (1998): 77-82.
______, "Crime
Prevention: The Community Policing Approach in Israel" In
International Perspective on Community Policing and Crime Prevention,
Edited by Stanley Lab and Dilip Das, Prentice Hall, 2002.
Haberfeld,
Maki & Herzog, Sergio, (2000). "The Criminal Justice
System in Israel." In Comparative and International Criminal
Justice Systems: Policing, Judiciary and Corrections, Edited
by Ebbe Obi, 55-78, New York: Butterworth / Heinemman, 2000.
Hasin, Yael.
& Horovitz, Menahem, "Juvenile and Adult Probation in
Israel", In Crime and Criminal Justice in Israel,
Edited by Robert R. Friedmann, 315-336. State University of New
York Press, Albany, USA, SUNY Series in Israeli Studies, 1998.
Herzog, Sergio.
(2000a). "The Treatment of Illegal-Use-of-Force Complaints
Against Police Officers in Israel: The Beleaguered Path to Civilian
Involvement", Police Quarterly, vol. 2, no.4 (2000a):
477-501.
______, "Evaluating
the New Civilian Police Complaints Board in Israel." In Civilian
Oversight of Complaints Against Police: Governance, Democracy
and Human Rights, Edited by Andrew Goldsmith & Colleen
Lewis , 125-146. Oxford: Hart Publishing Co., 2000b.
______, "Border
Closures as a Reliable Method for the Measurement of Palestinian
Involvement in Crime in Israel: A Quasi-Experimental Analysis,"
International Journal of Comparative Criminology, vol.
3, no.1 (2003): 18-41.
Israel Police,
Annual Reports.
Israel Prison
Service, Annual Reports.
Kremnitzer,
Mordechai, "Criminal Law in Israel", In Crime and
Criminal Justice in Israel: Assessing the Knowledge Base Toward
the Twenty-First Century, Edited by Robert R. Friedmann, 185-205.
State University of New York Press, Albany, USA, SUNY Series in
Israeli Studies, 1998.
Landau, Simcha.
F. "Crimes of Violence In Israel: Theoretical and Empirical
Perspectives", In Crime and Criminal Justice in Israel:
Assessing the Knowledge Base Toward the Twenty-First Century,
Edited by Robert R. Friedmann, 97-120. State University of New
York Press, 1998.
Rahav, Giora.
"Criminal Statistics", In Crime and Criminal Justice
in Israel: Assessing the Knowledge Base Toward the Twenty-First
Century, Edited by Robert R. Friedmann, 65-78. State University
of New York Press, Albany, USA, SUNY Series in Israeli Studies,
1998.
Sebba, Leslie.
"[Prison Labour in] Israel", In Prison Labour: Salvation
or Slavery? International Perspectives, Edited by F Dunkel
and D. VanZyl Smit, 115-144. Darmouth, Aldershot, 1999.
Sebba, Leslie.,
Horovitz, Menahem & Geva, Ruth. Israel, Criminal Justice
Systems in Europe and North America, HEUNI, Finland, 2003.
Shadmi, Erella.
"Police and Police Reform in Israel: The Formative Role of
the State", In Crime and Criminal Justice in Israel: Assessing
the Knowledge Base Toward the Twenty-First Century, Edited
by Robert R. Friedmann, 207-241. State University of New York
Press, 1998.
Shavitt,
Gabriel. "The Israeli Prison System", In Crime and
Criminal Justice in Israel, Edited by Robert R. Friedmann,
275-313. State University of New York Press, Albany, USA, SUNY
Series in Israeli Studies, 1998.
Weiss, Shoshana.
In internet web site of the National Anti-Drug Authority: www.
antidrugs.org.il, 2002.
Weisburd,
David., Shalev, Orit and Amir, Menahem. Community Policing
in Israel: A National Evaluation, Bureau of the Chief Scientist,
Jerusalem: Ministry of Public Security, Israel, 2001.(English
summary)
Wozner, Yochanan.
"Rehabilitation Efforts in the Israel Prison Service",
In Crime and Criminal Justice in Israel: Assessing the Knowledge
Base Toward the Twenty-First Century, Edited by Robert R.
Friedmann, 337-355. State University of New York Press, Albany,
USA, SUNY Series in Israeli Studies, 1998.
Bein, D.
"Criminal Law", In The Law of Israel: General Survey
Edited by Israel Zamir and S. Colombo, Haifa: University of Haifa,
Israel, 1995.
Friedmann,
Robert R. (ed.), Crime and Criminal Justice in Israel: Assessing
the Knowledge Base Toward the Twenty-First Century, State
University of New York Press, Albany, USA, SUNY Series in Israeli
Studies, 1998.
______, compiler,
An Annotated Bibliography of English Language Publications,
1948-1993, Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 1995.
Geva, R.
"Innovative Methods for Crime Prevention in Israel and International
Cooperation as the Means for Furthering These Methods", In
The Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders in IsraelA
Report, Prepared for the Eighth UN Congress on the Prevention
of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders, Cuba, August, 1990, 48-55.
1990.
______, "The
Founding and Recent Activities of the National Crime Reduction
Council in Israel", In The Prevention of Crime and the
Treatment of Offenders in IsraelA Report, Prepared for
the Eighth UN Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment
of Offenders, Cuba, 1990, 56-64. 1990.
______, "Feelings
of Insecurity and Fear and Cooperation with the Police: The Israeli
Experience", In International Faces of Victimology,
Edited by Sarah Ben David, and G.F. Kirchoff, 281-291. WSV Publishing,
Monchengladbach, 1992.
______, "Crime
Prevention Strategies: Twenty-Year Summary", Innovation
Exchange, Issue 7 Jerusalem: Ministry of Public Security,
Israel (1998), 28-37.
Horovitz,
Menahem, "Juvenile Justice in Israel", In The Prevention
of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders in IsraelA Report,
Prepared for the Eighth UN Congress on the Prevention of Crime
and the Treatment of Offenders, Cuba, August, 1990,105-114. 1990.
Ohana, D.
"Sentencing Reform in Israel: The Goldberg Committee Report",
Israel Law Review, vol. 32, (1998): 591- 643.
Sebba, Leslie.
"Sanctioning Policy in Israel - an Historical Overview",
Israel Law Review, vol. 30, (1996): 234-275.
______, "Victims' Rights and Legal Strategies: Israel as
a Case Study", Criminal Law Forum, vol. 11, (2000):
47-100.
Table
1: Reported Crime and Crime Rates in Israel: 1994-2003
|
Year
|
Total
Reported Files*
|
%
Change in Reported Crime from Previous Year
|
Average
Population**
|
Crime
Rate(per 1,000 population)
|
|
1994
|
386,066
|
-
|
5,471,500
|
70.5
|
|
1995
|
411,531
|
6.60
|
5,612,300
|
73.3
|
|
1996
|
438,063
|
6.45
|
5,685,100
|
77.0
|
|
1997
|
498,550
|
13.81
|
5,826,900
|
85.5
|
|
1998
|
516,435
|
3.59
|
5,970,700
|
85.5
|
|
1999
|
484,950
|
-6.10
|
6,125,300
|
79.2
|
|
2000
|
466,038
|
-3.90
|
6,289,200
|
74.1
|
|
2001
|
469,073
|
0.65
|
6,439,000
|
72.8
|
|
2002
|
464,854
|
-0.90
|
6,570,000
|
70.7
|
|
2003
|
484,688
|
4.27
|
6,750,000
|
71.8
|
Sources:
*http://www.police.gov.il/english/Crime/Trend_Analysis/xx_trends.asp
** http://147.237.248.51/shnaton54/st02_01.pdf
Sample
Entries
Description
| Introduction | A-Z
Entries List | Contributors
| Reviews
Order
Information | Order Online
| Contact Us | Routledge
Library Reference Home